It is known that primate red-green color vision is efficient at encoding the
presence of red or yellow fruit or leaves against a background of green foliage.
Separately, we have shown that images of red fruit and red leaves have Fourier
spectra that appear to be optimally encoded by the spatio-chromatic properties
of primate vision. However, our observations of monkey foraging behavior in
Kibale Forest, Uganda during the dry season suggested that monkeys frequently
ate green leaves on trees lacking any red object. They also showed preferences
for specific trees. We asked whether the neural encoding of the green leaves
of such trees allows discrimination from other trees, across marked differences
in illumination due to time-of-day and weather effects. We obtained 80 images
of two scenes, each containing several types of tree, throughout two days
at intervals of 10-20 minutes, using a calibrated digital camera system described
elsewhere (Párraga, Troscianko, and Tolhurst (2002) Current Biology
12, 483-487). The camera calibration allowed the decomposition of each pixel
into L,M,S cone responses, and also luminance, red-green, and yellow-blue
opponent responses. We averaged the values of these responses in five separate
patches for images from Day 1, and six patches for Day 2. Our first analysis
replicated the approach of Nascimento, Ferreira, and Foster (2002) JOSA A
19, 1484-1490, who suggested that ratios of cone responses across different
patches should be invariant against changes in illumination. This turned out
not to give a stable representation, especially when one of the patches was
plunged into shadow. However, if similar ratios are taken of the opponent-channel
responses, these ratios are more invariant across illumination changes by
an order of magnitude. In particular, the red-green system gives a particularly
stable ratio. We therefore conclude that the red-green opponent system provides
information about scenes containing green leaves which is strongly invariant
across changes in illumination direction, spectral composition, and intensity.
In other words, for scenes containing foliage, the colour constancy problem
is solved at the level of the retina.
|